Frames, data and knowledge for collective activism

Talk for Bristol Interaction Group
18 November 2026
Slides & refs: sjjg.uk/big

Engraving of Chartists clashing with police

Making evidence

“Accelerationist” technologies are changing how organisations manufacture* evidence

Machines are ‘witnesses’ permitted to manufacture evidence

* “Manufacture” is not a value judgement.

How are you feeling today?

What might this look like?

Where I work, you can opt into a daily media digest

You can imagine an agent producing this — sniffing around the internet, choosing what’s important based on some system prompt and sending this out to the staff (what’s left of it)

Screenshot of an email: “Daily media summary – Thursday 12 November 2026”, with news items about Cardiff University

What about the folks who want to challenge organisations’ evidence (and their actions based on it)?

Imagine… just imagine

The University of Bristol has a new workload model

It’s called the Model for Academic Delivery*

You and your colleagues are disgruntled with this and decide to band together to do something about it. Congrats, you’re activists

Engraving of two bal maidens breaking ore with hammers

* This is a work of fiction. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental.

You’re a bunch of academics,

so you form a task and finish group and hold a meeting…

“Who are we trying to persuade? Management won’t listen!”

    These kinds of discussions among activists are called “frame disputes” .

    This is an example of “frame resonance”, where activists debate how to present themselves and their counternarratives to different audiences.

    An open glass cold frame against a brick wall
    Photo by T on Unsplash

    The other two components of frame disputes

    According to well-cited paper…

    Diagnostic

    Aspects of the debate that relate to what the underlying problem is that needs to be addressed

    Prognostic

    Aspects of the debate that relate to what the state of the world ought to be if the activists had their way — and what needs to happen next

    “The problem is that management have no idea how our work is produced!”

      These kinds of discussions among activists are called “frame disputes” .

      This is an example of diagnostic deliberation in a frame dispute, the way in which activists explore and seek to define what the underlying problems are

      Plants and flowers growing among rocks in a greenhouse

      The other two components of frame disputes

      According to well-cited paper…

      Resonance

      Activists debate how to present themselves and their counternarratives to different audiences

      Prognostic

      Aspects of the debate that relate to what the state of the world ought to be if the activists had their way — and what needs to happen next

      “We need a workplace where staff set workload tariffs, if we don’t, this place is finished!”

        These kinds of discussions among activists are called “frame disputes” .

        This is an example of a prognostic frame dispute: folks debate what the state of the world ought to be if they had their way — and what needs to happen next.

        Plants beneath the geometric glass roof of a greenhouse
        Photo by Kate Bezzubets on Unsplash

        The other two components of frame disputes

        According to well-cited paper…

        Resonance

        Activists debate how to present themselves and their counternarratives to different audiences

        Diagnostic

        Aspects of the debate that relate to what the underlying problem is that needs to be addressed

        Frame disputes

        You came to the question of how to proceed from different perspectives. (And that’s before we get to the substance of the positions.)

        Groups of activists have heterogeneity of structure and purpose; they often don’t have the kinds of binding hierarchies that allow organisations to certify and provide provenance.

        Frame disputes

        We know a fair bit about activists’ infrastructural use and repurposing in enacting activism.

        We don’t know about the pragmatics of these frame disputes (including the role digital infrastructures play in constraining these disputes and influencing how they unfold)

        An aerial view of a circular sewage treatment tank
        Photo by Patrick Federi on Unsplash

        Ways of knowing workload

        “We need a workplace where staff set workload tariffs, if we don’t, this place is finished!”

        This accepts the form of knowledge about workloads as settled. The campaign is then really about the accuracy of the data underpinning it.

        Activist epistemologies

        Activism is often agonistic in its nature

        There’s a risk of organisations’ ways of knowing capturing activists’ imagination for counternarratives

        For example, datafication is an effect of accelerationist technologies, and a risk to activists

        A heavy road roller under a cloudy sky
        Photo by chris robert on Unsplash

        Reject it?

        interviewees noted that “engaging with a data rights framework entails accepting particular assumptions about the future of work and the role of technology within it.”

        Refusal may be a necessary approach , focusing on aspects of activism outside the target organisations’ epistemic frame

        But some of these data-based approaches have been quite successful… (see, eg, )

        How would you contest the workload model?

        How would you contest the workload model?

        What to do?

        How to recognise epistemic capture, and ensure epistemic plurality?

        How to manage external agonism alongside internal agonism?

        How to build concurrent counternarratives for different audiences?

        How to manage privacy in different ways of knowing?

        How to manage structural heterogeneity within collectives?

        A mop beside a cleaning bucket
        Photo by Spruce Refillable Cleaning on Unsplash

        Privacy

        Individual data rights can obscure the collective nature of data bargaining

        There are risks to data pooling, but there are ways to ameliorate them

        But how do we look at privacy across epistemologies and ontologies? A video about how consumers have been affected by dodgy insulation can’t follow the same privacy model as for spreadsheets returned by subject access requests. How could all this be negotiated?

        Epistemic capture

        How could activist collectives be facilitated to knowingly accept epistemic capture, or to strategically resist it?

        Within a given campaign, both approaches may be required to serve different audiences at different moments.

        How to work on them simultaneously? Boundary objects from design ? Standpoint logic from KR ? Reapprehension from STS ?

        Dunno! But it seems important to work out how intentional technology design could support it.

        Lighthouse on a harbour wall at dawn

        What now?

        Tech is changing how organisations produce evidence and act on it

        Activist collectives have a critical democratic role that’s threatened by these technologies

        What could we learn from building tech with these groups, tech that supported heterogeneous hierarchies, goals, epistemologies?

        What would that tech look like? (I don’t know yet!)

        Diolch yn fawr

        Oes cwestiynau gyda chi?

        Thank you very much

        Do you have any questions?

        Slides & refs: sjjg.uk/big

        Autumn foliage above a brick wall beneath a bridge

        References

        References (continued)

        Image sources

        1. Title slide: Alfred Pearse, “Chartists’ Riots”, engraving in Cornelius Brown, True Stories of the Reign of Queen Victoria (1886). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped.
        2. Scenario: Bal maidens spalling ore, engraving from James Henderson’s paper in Minutes of Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers (1858). Public domain, via Wikipedia. Cropped.
        3. Frame resonance: photograph by T on Unsplash. Cropped.
        4. Prognostic frame dispute: photograph by Kate Bezzubets on Unsplash. Cropped.
        5. Activist epistemologies: photograph by chris robert on Unsplash. Cropped.
        6. Ways of knowing workload: photograph by Patrick Federi on Unsplash. Cropped.
        7. What to do?: photograph by Spruce Refillable Cleaning on Unsplash. Cropped.